Advertiser Disclosure We earn a commission from partner links on StartupWise. Commissions do not affect our opinions or evaluations.

C-Corp vs. S-Corp: The Crucial Reasons to Consider Before Forming a C-Corp

Share:

Table of Contents

Selecting the proper business structure is more than just what looks good on paper. The decision must reflect your business’s personality, goals, and the path you envision for its growth. In the world of business entities, S-Corporations (S-Corps) and C-Corporations (C-Corps) are two styles that, while similar in name, differ significantly in their fit for various business types. With a spotlight on C-Corps, we’ll separate the complexities of this business structure, shedding light on its benefits and potential drawbacks. By comparing it directly with its counterpart, the S-Corp, we will guide you through the complicated decision-making process, helping you choose the business structure that aligns perfectly with your long-term objectives.

What is a C Corp?

A C Corporation, or C Corp, is a business entity separate from its owners. Think of it as an independent person who can earn money, be taxed, and be held legally liable. This setup provides a strong separation between the business and the personal assets of its owners, protecting those owners if the company has debts or legal troubles.

Do C Corps Get 1099?

Quick detour: a 1099 form is used to report income other than wages, salaries, and tips (the income reported on a W-2 form). For C Corps, it’s a bit different. C Corps don’t usually get 1099 forms because they’re considered separate entities, and the IRS tracks their earnings differently. Instead, they deal with forms like the 1120, their tax return, to independent contractors who’ve paid over $600 in a fiscal year.

S Corp vs. C Corp

The main difference between S Corps and C Corps lies in how they are taxed. C Corps are taxed separately from their owners, while S Corps are “pass-through” entities, meaning the business’s income and losses pass through to the owners’ tax returns. 

Let’s see the differences between S-Corps and C-Corps in a point-by-point comparison:

Taxation:

  • S-Corp: Profits and losses pass through to the shareholders’ tax returns, avoiding double taxation.
  • C-Corp: This type of corporation is subject to double taxation, where the corporation pays corporate income tax, and shareholders pay taxes on dividends.

Ownership Restrictions:

  • S-Corp: This type of corporation is limited to 100 shareholders, all of whom must be U.S. citizens or residents and can only have one class of stock.
  • C-Corp: No limit on the number of shareholders, can have international shareholders, and can issue multiple classes of stock.

Fiscal Year:

  • S-Corp: In most cases, it must adopt a calendar year as its fiscal year.
  • C-Corp: Can choose its fiscal year.

Stock:

  • S-Corp: Only one class of stock is allowed, limiting the company’s ability to raise capital from various equity preferences.
  • C-Corp: Can issue multiple classes of stock, which is attractive to venture capitalists and investors seeking different voting rights and dividend preferences.

Regulatory and Compliance Requirements:

  • S-Corp: Generally faces fewer regulatory hurdles and compliance requirements than a C-Corp.
  • C-Corp: Faces more stringent regulatory requirements and compliance standards.

Pros and Cons: C-Corp and S-Corp

C Corporations Pros:

  • Suitable for Raising Capital: Investors love C Corps because they’re familiar with and have clear rules, making investing more accessible.
  • Flexible Fiscal Year: C Corps can choose their financial year, which can help plan taxes better.
  • Limited Liability Protection: Like a shield, a C Corp protects your assets from business troubles.
  • No Tax on Reinvested Profits: Money back into the business doesn’t get taxed immediately.

C Corporations Cons:

  • Double Taxation: The company pays taxes, and then you pay taxes again on what you earn.
  • Higher Regulatory Requirements: C Corps have more rules to follow, which can be a headache.
  • Ongoing Costs: Keeping up with legal and accounting stuff can get pricey.
  • Not Ideal for Most Small Businesses: Because of the double taxation and extra costs, many small businesses might find C Corps too bulky.

 

S Corporations Pros:

  • Avoids Double Taxation: Only the shareholders are taxed on their income from the corporation, not the corporation itself.
  • Investment Opportunities: While less appealing than C-Corps to investors, S-Corps can still attract investment without double taxation.
  • Business Expense Tax Credits: Shareholders can deduct business losses on their tax returns.

S Corporations Cons:

  • Shareholder Restrictions: Limited to 100 shareholders must be U.S. citizens or residents.
  • Stock Restrictions: Can only issue one class of stock, potentially limiting investment opportunities.
  • Salary Requirements: Shareholders who work for the company must receive a reasonable salary subject to employment tax.

Which is Best for LLC: S-Corp vs. C-Corp?

If your business is an LLC, you can be taxed as an S-Corp or a C-Corp. The right choice depends on your business goals, size, and financial plans. S-Corp taxation can benefit small to medium businesses, prioritizing tax savings and simpler distributions over raising large amounts of capital.

Should I Form a C-Corp?
C corporations are not a good fit for most small businesses. They have double taxation and higher regulatory requirements and costs. An LLC or an S corporation would be a better choice. Check out our video on why you should NOT form a C Corp.

Forming a C Corp makes sense if:

  • You’re planning to go public or attract big investors.
  • You want flexibility in setting your fiscal year.
  • You’re okay with dealing with more paperwork and regulations for protection and growth potential.

If these sound like they’re not your cup of tea, or if you’re keeping things small and simple, think twice.

How to Form a C Corporation

Forming a C Corp involves a few steps:

  1. Choose a Name: It has to be unique and not already taken by another business.
  2. File Articles of Incorporation: This is like your company’s birth certificate.
  3. Appoint Directors: These are the people who will oversee big company decisions.
  4. Create Bylaws: The rulebook on how your company runs.
  5. Get Licenses and Permits: Depending on what your business does, you might need special permissions.
  6. Issue Stock: This is how you get investors on board.

Tax Return and Tax Requirement

Tax Return

C-Corps file a corporate tax return (Form 1120) and pay taxes at the corporate rate on any profits. If dividends are distributed to shareholders, those dividends are taxed again on the shareholders’ tax returns.

Tax Requirement and Due

In addition to regular income taxes, C-Corps may be subject to various state and federal taxes, such as employment and excise taxes, depending on the nature of the business. The exact tax due dates can vary, but generally, C-Corps must pay estimated taxes quarterly if they expect to owe $500 or more in corporate taxes for the year.

Bottom Line

While C-Corps offers full opportunities for growth and investment, they’re not a one-size-fits-all solution. While the appeal of attracting venture capital and the prestige of a corporate structure may be tempting, it’s essential to consider the practical implications, especially the impact of double taxation and the administrative burden.

For many smaller businesses and LLCs contemplating their next move, an S-Corp might provide a more suitable blend of liability protection and tax advantages without the complexities of a C-Corp. Ultimately, your choice should align with your business strategy, financial goals, and plans to scale your operations.

Remember, it’s always wise to consult with a financial advisor or a tax professional to help navigate these decisions. They can provide personalized advice based on your business scenario, ensuring you choose the path that best supports your ambitions and growth potential.

Form your C Corp quickly and easily!  

Northwest Registered Agent can handle the paperwork for just $39 (exclusive offer). Get your C Corp set up right to enjoy benefits like limited liability and easier fundraising. This is a limited-time deal, so don’t miss out! Get started with Northwest Registered Agent today and make your C Corp dream a reality.  

Bonus: They can also help form S Corps and LLCs!

FAQs

  • Is a C-Corp or S-Corp better for a startup?

    It depends on your business goals and funding needs. Startups seeking venture capital may prefer a C-Corp for its flexible stock options and no shareholder limit. However, startups looking to avoid double taxation with fewer shareholders might find an S-Corp more advantageous.

  • Can I switch from a C-Corp to an S-Corp if my business changes?

    A C-Corp can elect to become an S-Corp by filing IRS Form 2553. However, there are eligibility requirements to meet, and the switch may have tax implications, so it’s wise to consult with a tax professional.

  • Are there specific industries where a C-Corp is more beneficial than an S-Corp?

    Industries that require significant investment capital, such as technology and manufacturing, may benefit more from a C-Corp structure due to its attractiveness to outside investors and the ability to issue multiple classes of stock.

  • How does having shareholders outside the U.S. affect my choice between S-Corp and C-Corp?

    If you have or plan to have shareholders who are not U.S. citizens or residents, you must form a C-Corp, as S-Corps are restricted to U.S. citizens and residents only.

  • What happens if an S-Corp exceeds the 100-shareholder limit?

    If an S-corporation exceeds the shareholder limit, it risks losing its status and being treated as a C-corporation, including being subject to double taxation. Therefore, it’s essential to monitor shareholder numbers closely.

  • Can an S-Corp own a C-Corp (or vice versa)?

    Yes, an S-corporation can own a C-corporation, and an S-corporation can own a C-corporation. However, specific tax implications and regulations surround this, so detailed tax advice is essential.

  • Where to File C-Corp 1120 Form?

    Form 1120, the U.S. Corporation Income Tax Return, is a crucial document for C-corporations as it details their income, gains, losses, deductions, and credits. The filing location for Form 1120 can depend on the corporation’s physical location and whether payment is included.

    Generally, the IRS provides specific addresses for mailing the tax return, categorized by state and whether a payment is included. However, for the most accurate and updated information on where to file, it’s best to refer to the instructions provided with Form 1120 on the IRS website or consult a tax professional. 

    Additionally, corporations can file Form 1120 electronically through the IRS e-file system, which is faster and often more convenient than paper filing.

  • Can a C-Corp Own an LLC?

    Yes, a C-Corp can own an LLC (Limited Liability Company). This setup allows corporations to diversify their business operations and take advantage of the LLC’s flexible management structure and pass-through taxation (unless the LLC elects to be taxed as a corporation). 

     

    Here are some considerations:

    • Tax Implications: The LLC’s income can pass through to the C-Corp, affecting its taxable income. If the LLC elects to be taxed as a corporation, it would pay corporate taxes, and then the C-Corp would be taxed again on any dividends received, potentially leading to double taxation.

    • Legal Considerations: The C-Corp must comply with state laws regarding LLC ownership, which can vary. It’s essential to ensure that the C-Corp’s ownership of the LLC is documented and that both entities maintain separate records and finances to preserve the LLC’s liability protection.

    • Operational Flexibility: Owning an LLC can give a C-Corp operational flexibility. LLCs have fewer compliance requirements and can adapt more quickly to changes in the business environment than corporations.

Submit Your Email to Download Freebies